crowdsided
โš–๏ธ Big debates

How many holes does a straw have?

Short answer: Mathematically, one. In topology, the two openings are two ends of a single hole.

Play ยท 1/8๐Ÿ”ฅ 0๐Ÿบ Lone Wolf

Agree or disagree?

โ€œA straw has one hole.โ€

or

The case for

  • One hole: itโ€™s one tunnel with two ends.
  • In topology, a straw is a circle stretched along a length.
  • A donut has one hole, and a straw is a tall, thin donut.

The case against

  • Two holes: you can see one at each end.
  • Zero holes: itโ€™s a sheet rolled up, and a sheet has no holes.
  • Seal one end and it looks like a cup, which has no hole at all.

What we actually know

Sources

More debates