The trolley problem: would you pull the lever?
Three versions of the same choice. Vote on each, then see how 70,000 people answered.
What would you do?
A runaway trolley will hit five people. You can pull a lever to send it toward one person instead. Do you pull it?
Short answer: There is no agreed right answer. In a study of 70,000 people in 42 countries, an average of 81% approved of pulling the lever to save five people at the cost of one, but only 51% approved of pushing a man off a footbridge to do the same.
The three versions
In each one, five people die if you do nothing and one person dies if you act. The share is the average, across countries, of people who approved of acting.
The switch
A runaway trolley is about to kill five workers. You can pull a lever to send it down a side track, where it will kill one worker instead.
81% approved of acting
The loop
The side track loops back toward the five. Sending the trolley there saves them only because the one workerβs body stops it.
72% approved of acting
The footbridge
There is no lever. You are on a bridge over the track, and the only way to stop the trolley is to push a large man in front of it.
51% approved of acting
Why the answers change
The case for acting
- Five lives saved against one lost is the better result.
- Choosing to do nothing is still a choice.
- The numbers are the same in all three versions.
The case against
- Causing a death is different from failing to prevent one.
- On the footbridge, the man is used as a tool to stop the trolley.
- Pushing someone with your own hands feels unlike pulling a lever.
What we actually know
- The study analyzed answers from 70,000 participants in 10 languages and 42 countries, collected through MITβs Moral Machine website.
- Approval was highest for the switch (81%), then the loop (72%), then the footbridge (51%).
- Every country in the study showed that same order.
- The trolley cases go back to a 1967 paper by the philosopher Philippa Foot. Judith Jarvis Thomson developed them in papers from 1976 and 1985.
- According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, many people believe it is permissible to divert the trolley and wrong to push a bystander.
Sources
- Awad, Dsouza, Shariff, Rahwan and Bonnefon (2020), βUniversals and variations in moral decisions made in 42 countries by 70,000 participants,β PNAS 117(5)
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Doctrine of Double Effect