Real poem or AI?
Ten short poems. Some are by Emily Dickinson, John Keats, Walt Whitman, Robert Frost and other poets, some were written by AI. Which are real?
Where the passages come from
Every real passage is copied word for word from a public-domain book on Project Gutenberg: novels by Jane Austen, Charles Dickens, Mary Shelley, Mark Twain, H. G. Wells and others, and poems by Emily Dickinson, John Keats, Walt Whitman and more. After you guess, you see the book it came from.
Every AI passage was written by an AI model for this game, asked to imitate the same kind of writing. Nothing is edited to make it easier or harder, and the answer is only sent to your browser after you guess.
The “players got this right” numbers are real guesses from real players. We never add made-up votes.
How to spot AI writing
- Sounding old proves nothing. AI is very good at old-fashioned words and long sentences. Look past the style.
- Neat endings are a clue. AI loves a tidy, quotable twist in the last few words (“…and the cake was never mentioned again”). Real novels are messier, because a sentence usually serves the story, not the punchline.
- Strange, specific details are hard to fake. Real authors mention things that only make sense inside their story: a receipt for a debt, tallow dripping off a candle, a tow-head in a river. AI tends to reach for familiar props: clocks, fog, candles, rain.
- Real lines often start mid-story. A real sentence may lean on something that happened before it. AI lines tend to be complete little scenes on their own.
- Poems: watch the rhyme. AI rhymes very regularly and rarely surprises. Dickinson’s odd dashes and half-rhymes, or Whitman’s long rambling lists, are hard for it to copy convincingly.
More games
FAQ
- Is the real text really from those books?
- Yes. Every real passage is copied word for word from a public-domain book on Project Gutenberg, and the book and author are shown after you guess.
- Who wrote the AI passages?
- An AI model wrote them for this game, imitating the style of 19th- and early 20th-century novels and poems. They are not edited by hand.
- How often is there a new round?
- The daily Real or AI? round has 10 new passages every day at midnight UTC. The quizzes are fixed sets of 10 you can play any time.
- Can I see the answers without playing?
- No. The answer for each passage is only sent after you guess, so nobody can look it up in the page.
- Do I need an account?
- No. Your score and streak are saved in your browser only.